March 10, 2026

470. Why Your Podcast Needs a Pre-Interview

Show Notes

You finally book a guest you’re excited about. You press the record button, you’re off… and suddenly the answers drift into promotion, your guest goes on irrelevant tangents, and the episode never seems to find its legs. Many podcasters learn this lesson the hard way. Today, we talk about one of the simplest ways to protect the listener experience before the recording ever starts. Today, our conversation is about the role of the pre-interview and why it can make the difference between a scattered interview and a focused, engaging episode. We look at how a short conversation ahead of time can help shape the story, set expectations, and make sure both host and guest are ready to serve the audience. Then we take it a step further. Instead of just talking about the idea, we demonstrate it. We improvise a couple of mock pre-interviews so you can hear what the process actually sounds like and how it helps set up a stronger episode.

Episode Highlights:

[02:46] Why pre-interviews matter

[05:56] Vetting guests and protecting audience fit

[15:20] Tech checks, links, and logistics before recording

[17:35] The anti pre-interview perspective

[26:38] Matt and Sid roleplay session

[34:23] Setting interview guardrails

[36:39] Improv scenario with audio issues

[39:53] Handling unprepared or promotional guests

[41:15] Debrief on coaching language and jargon

[52:07] Name pronunciation and final prep

Links & Resources: